+352 27 75 72 00 Mail us
1, Place du Théâtre - L2613 Luxembourg

Public Procurement Act: what might change for public procurement in Luxembourg

Image décrivant le Public Procurement Act dans un contexte de cabinet d'avocat au Luxembourg

On 9 September 2026, the European Commission presented its proposal for the ‘Public Procurement Act’, which overhauls the bulk of European law on public procurement and concessions.

This text has not yet been adopted and will evolve as negotiations progress, but it already sets out the rules that contracting authorities and economic operators may have to apply in Luxembourg within a few years’ time.

An update on the announced changes and the next steps.

1. Public procurement in Luxembourg: a European regulation to replace the directives

The proposal for a regulation COM(2026) 590 provides for the repeal of the three 2014 directives on public procurement, special sectors and concessions, and for the consolidation of their rules into a single text comprising 149 articles.

The explanatory memorandum summarises this decision in a single sentence:

‘The proposal simplifies the legal framework by replacing the three existing Directives with a single directly applicable Regulation.’

This change in legal instrument has practical implications: a directive must be transposed into national law, whereas a regulation applies as it stands in each Member State.

The Luxembourg legislature would therefore not need to transpose this text, but it would need to amend the amended Public Procurement Law of 8 April 2018, its implementing regulations and the Act of 3 July 2018 on the award of concession contracts, to remove any provisions that would duplicate or contradict the Regulation.

The scope of the reform is, however, subject to three limitations.

The procurement rules apply only to contracts that reach the European thresholds (Article 2), the current amounts of which are set out — notably €5,404,000 excluding VAT for works and concessions, €216,000 excluding VAT for supplies and services — so that contracts of a lower value (national contracts under Book I) would, in principle, remain governed by national law.

Nor does the proposal amend the ‘remedies’ directives: the remedies available before the Luxembourg administrative courts are therefore not directly called into question at this stage.

From this perspective, it might be appropriate for the legislator to consider reviewing the formal requirements for the service of appeals in public procurement matters. Indeed, in addition to the costs of bailiffs and translation, the significant delays (sometimes running to several months) inherent in the service of appeals for interim relief with suspensive effect in foreign countries can substantially delay the signing of public contracts and, consequently, the commencement of certain projects.

One idea worth exploring would be to allow an unsuccessful tenderer to request the contracting authority to forward their appeal to the relevant tenderers via the Public Procurement Portal, which is already a valid channel for all communications.

Finally, it should be noted that Member States retain some room for manoeuvre, for example to make the division of contracts mandatory (Article 100) or to further restrict subcontracting where there is an increased risk of non-compliance with social and labour law (Article 24), and each of them will be required to designate a national coordinating authority (Article 138).

2. Public procurement: three procedures and a generalised negotiation process

The Commission has announced a streamlined framework, “with three procedures instead of five currently”.

The open procedure and the dynamic procedure will become the two standard procedures, applicable regardless of the subject matter of the contract, whilst an innovation procedure will enable a solution to be developed where no existing solution adequately meets the need.

The main new feature concerns negotiation: the public purchaser may resort to this in both the open procedure and the dynamic procedure, provided that they have announced it in their contract notice, now renamed the ‘public summary of the call for competition’.

However, such negotiation is limited to the non-essential characteristics of the services and may not relate to grounds for exclusion, selection criteria or award criteria (Article 33).

Furthermore, a special procedure, without prior competitive tendering, replaces the current negotiated procedure without publication; it remains restricted to specific cases — notably exclusivity, extreme urgency not attributable to the contracting authority, or certain supplementary deliveries — and requires the publication of a summary of the outcome (Articles 46 to 48).

Several rules are of direct interest to tenderers:

  • the minimum deadline for the submission of tenders in open procedures is set at 20 days (Article 34), compared with 35 days at present, or 30 days in the case of electronic submission;
  • the minimum turnover requirement may no longer exceed 50 per cent of the estimated annual value of the contract, except in duly justified cases (Article 27), whereas the current ceiling is, in principle, twice the estimated value of the contract;
  • new optional grounds for exclusion have been introduced, relating to foreign subsidies distorting the internal market and a lack of reliability with regard to public safety and security (Article 26);
  • a European electronic service verifies the grounds for exclusion, the selection criteria and the origin in accordance with the ‘once-and-for-all’ principle ’ principle (Article 133), with its implementation announced as being phased in.

As for the division of contracts into lots, this remains a matter for the contracting authority to consider, justifying its choice when it decides not to divide the contract:

‘Public buyers shall consider whether to divide contracts into lots’ (Article 100(1))

3. Award of public contracts: minimum quality standards and preference for European suppliers

The Commission begins with an observation, set out in the explanatory memorandum: ‘Contracts awarded solely on the basis of price remain the norm’.

Article 98 aims to reverse this trend by making the best value for money the rule and price alone the exception:

Article 98 · Award criteria

1.Public buyers shall award the contract to the economic operator that offers the best quality for money.

To that effect, public buyers shall evaluate the tenders received according to the best price-quality ratio method referred to in paragraph 2, and by applying award criteria with the minimum quality weighting in accordance with paragraph 4, except as provided for in paragraph 5.

2.To determine the best price-quality ratio, public buyers shall evaluate the tenders through a comparison of their price and quality, based on quality criteria linked to the subject-matter of the contract. Costs can also be taken into account when determining the best price-quality ratio.

Quality criteria shall refer to any criteria used to assess the degree to which a tender proposes beneficial, efficient or sustainable outcomes in relation to the subject-matter of the contract.

The quality of the tender may, for instance, relate to the following aspects:

(a) technical merit, aesthetic and functional characteristics, accessibility, design for all users, and production methods;

(b) environmental and climate-related considerations referred to in Article 50, food-specific considerations referred to in Article 53 where relevant, social considerations referred to in Article 55, innovation objectives referred to in Article 59, security and public safety interests as set out in Article 66, resilience and security of supply requirements as set out in Article 69, or European preference requirements where a public buyer applies those requirements in the form of an allocation of award points pursuant to Article 73(2), point (b);

(c) quality of the staff assigned that can significantly impact the level of performance of the contract, such as the organisation, qualification and experience of the staff assigned to performing the contract;

(d) after-sales service and technical assistance, delivery conditions such as date at which or period during which the delivery is to take place or to be completed.

Public buyers may also establish a fixed price on the basis of which economic operators are to compete on quality criteria only.

3.Award criteria shall be non-discriminatory, proportionate, specific, objective and measurable; they shall be evaluated in a process containing sufficient safeguards against irregularities. They shall allow the public buyer to effectively compare the strengths and weaknesses of the offered goods, services and works, and shall not have the effect of conferring an unrestricted freedom of choice on the public buyer.

Public buyers shall specify, in the public summary of competition, the criteria and their relative weighting chosen to determine the best price-quality ratio.

4. The weight of quality criteria shall represent at least 30 % of total points awarded.

For contracts where the subject-matter is labour-intensive, the weight of quality criteria shall represent at least 50 % of total points awarded.

Where, pursuant to Article 99, public buyers apply life-cycle costing, the weight given to life-cycle costs shall be counted within the respective percentage share.

Where public buyers apply environmental criteria specific for public procurement set in Union legislation as referred to in Article 50(4), second subparagraph, including delegated acts adopted pursuant to Article 54, and where those requirements relate to award criteria, the weight given to such environmental considerations shall count within percentages indicated in this paragraph. Mere compliance with obligations not relating to award criteria shall not be an award criterion.

5. Public buyers may derogate from paragraph 1, second subparagraph, and from paragraph 4, where the quality of the product, service or works procured can be ensured in any of the following ways:

(a) specifications;

(b) where relevant, conditions for the performance of contracts;

(c) a combination of any of the following: quality-based award criteria, specifications and conditions for the performance of contracts.

Public buyers shall indicate in the public summary of competition which of the ways set out in the first subparagraph justifies that derogation..

The purchaser therefore retains a fallback option, as it may derogate from these rules where the specifications or conditions for the performance of the contract – where applicable, in conjunction with quality criteria – are sufficient to ensure the expected quality, provided that the method chosen is specified in the contract notice.

Quality criteria may relate, in particular, to technical merit, the quality of the staff assigned to the contract where this influences its standard of performance, or social and environmental considerations, thereby building on the ongoing discussion regarding environmental clauses in public procurement.

The treatment of abnormally low tenders is also clarified: the contracting authority must request explanations where the price appears abnormally low — in comparison with other tenders, its own estimate or comparable previous contracts — and must reject the tender if these explanations are not deemed satisfactory (Article 101).

Finally, the text establishes a ‘European preference’ (Articles 70 to 77), which remains, in principle, an option for the contracting authority rather than an obligation.

The contracting authority may restrict the procedure to EU economic operators and ‘covered’ economic operators, give preference to European tenders during evaluation, or ‘reject a tender where the value of the EU or covered goods, services or works it contains is less than 50 per cent of the total estimated value of the tender’ (Article 73).

Operators, goods, services and works from third countries linked to the EU by an agreement opening up public procurement markets are deemed ‘covered’, within the limits of the commitments made; the Commission may also impose such requirements, by means of a delegated act, in respect of operators and services that are not covered (Article 75).

4. Implementation of public contracts: regulated subcontracting and simplified amendments

The proposal imposes stricter controls on subcontracting in public procurement by introducing, in Article 24, a prohibition not contained in the current Directives:

“A contract awarded to an economic operator shall not be subcontracted in its entirety, nor be further subcontracted in its entirety“

The tenderer must also indicate, in its tender, the parts of the contract it intends to subcontract and the proposed subcontractors, whilst the contracting authority may, where justified by the nature of the contract, reserve certain essential tasks for the main contractor.

The rules governing modifications during the performance of the contract have, for their part, been made clearer, with Article 106 establishing a single de minimis threshold:

“Modification, the value of which does not exceed 15 % of the value of the initial contract shall be considered non-substantial and may be made without a new procurement procedure, provided that the modification does not alter the initial economic balance of the contract.”

By way of comparison, Luxembourg law currently sets thresholds of 10 per cent for supplies and services and 15 per cent for works, and also requires that the European thresholds be observed.

Above 15 per cent, a modification remains possible if it is not substantial, and a substantial modification is still permitted in three cases — additional services that have become necessary where a change of contractor is not feasible, circumstances that a diligent contracting authority could not reasonably have foreseen, or replacement of the contractor, in particular following a reorganisation — without the text incorporating the 50 per cent cap per modification that current law applies to the first two cases.

This cap is replaced by a duty of transparency, whereby the purchaser must publish a summary of the amendment before finalising it where it exceeds 50 per cent of the contract’s initial value, except in emergency situations.

Two safeguards remain: the amendment must not upset the economic balance of the contract in favour of the contractor, nor be used to remedy shortcomings attributable to the contractor.

Adjustments made in accordance with clear, precise and unambiguous indexation clauses are not, however, considered to be amendments, provided that the mechanism is justified by the nature of the contract and preserves its economic balance (Article 105), which should encourage care to be taken in drafting such clauses as part of the contractual monitoring of contracts.

5. Timeline for the Public Procurement Act: the next steps

The text is following the ordinary legislative procedure, meaning that the European Parliament and the Council may still make substantial amendments to it.

  • 9 September 2026: the Commission adopts its proposal.
  • 11 November 2026: the Parliament announces that the matter has been referred to its Committee on the Internal Market (IMCO). The procedural sheet does not yet indicate a rapporteur for the substance.
  • 3 and 4 December 2026: the Competitiveness Council is due to hold a policy debate on the text.
  • End of 2027: the institutions aim to conclude negotiations in the fourth quarter of 2027, according to the European Parliament’s legislative tracking system.
  • Two years later: the regulation applies two years after its entry into force (Article 149). If this timetable is adhered to, the new rules would not apply until the end of 2029, or even 2030.

Until then, the amended Act of 8 April 2018 remains the reference text, and the proposal does not yet specify the fate of procedures already underway at the time of the transition.

From the perspective of contracting authorities, it would be advisable to trial quality criteria weighted at 30 per cent or more, as this point appears to be firmly established in the draft regulation.

From the perspective of economic operators, it will be useful to begin mapping out the use of subcontractors and the origin of the products offered as of now, as the proposal requires these details to be declared in tenders or verified.

❖

Our law firm advises public purchasers and tenderers on public procurement law in Luxembourg: please contact us to assess the impact of the Public Procurement Act on your procedures, tenders or current contracts.

Chevrier & Favari Avocats
Privacy Overview

This website uses cookies so that we can provide you with the best user experience possible. Cookie information is stored in your browser and performs functions such as recognising you when you return to our website and helping our team to understand which sections of the website you find most interesting and useful.